NHL Draft Grades: Instant Analysis of Every Team’s Picks

NHL Draft Grades: Instant Analysis of Every Team’s Picks image

The 2025 NHL Draft has concluded, and we’re grading each Atlantic Division team’s draft performance.

Jump to:
Atlantic | Central | Metropolitan | Pacific

Boston Bruins: A-

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
7 James Hagens C Boston College NCAA
51 William Moore C NTDP USHL
61 Liam Pettersson LHD Vaxjo Jr. Sweden Jr.
79 Cooper Simpson LW Shakopee HS-MN
100 Vashek Blanar LHD Troja-Ljungby Jr. Sweden Jr.
133 Cole Chandler C Shawinigan QMJHL
165 Kirill Yemelyanov C Yaroslavl Jr. MHL

Boston completely rebuilt their center depth with two excellent picks.

James Hagens was projected as the top pick entering this draft cycle. While he didn’t match the freshman NCAA production of players like Macklin Celebrini and Adam Fantilli, he still brings first-line potential with his speed and hockey IQ. Getting Hagens at seventh overall represents excellent value for the Bruins.

William Moore provides tremendous value in the back half of the second round. He posted nearly a point per game with the NTDP this season.

The Bruins’ strategy focused on addressing their most pressing organizational need while capitalizing on unexpected draft board movement.

Buffalo Sabres: B

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
9 Radim Mrtka RHD Seattle WHL
71 David Bedkowski RHD Owen Sound OHL
103 Matous Kucharcik C Slavia Jr. Czechia Jr.
116 Samuel Meloche G Rouyn-Noranda QMJHL
135 Noah Laberge LHD Acadie-Bathurst QMJHL
167 Ashton Schultz C Chicago USHL
195 Melvin Novotny LW Leksand Jr. Sweden Jr.
199 Yevgeni Prokhorov G Dinamo-Shinnik Jr. MHL
219 Ryan Rucinski C Youngstown USHL

Radim Mrtka brings top-four shutdown potential with his 6-foot-6 frame and solid skating ability. He can move the puck effectively without being overly creative with his distribution.

David Bedkowski also brings size at 6-foot-5 and plays a physical style that complements his defensive game.

Buffalo emphasized size and defensive depth throughout their draft, addressing organizational needs while maintaining reasonable upside across multiple rounds.

Carolina Hurricanes: B+

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
13 Carter Bear LW Everett WHL
44 Eddie Genborg RW Linkoping SHL
75 Michal Pradel G Tri-City USHL
109 Brent Solomon RW Champlin Park HS-MN
119 Michal Svrcek LW Brynas Jr. Sweden Jr.
140 Nikita Tyurin LHD Spartak Jr. MHL
172 Will Murphy LHD Cape Breton QMJHL
204 Grayden Robertson-Palmer C Phillips Andover HS-MA

Carter Bear’s competitiveness and tenacity stand out immediately. He projects as a top-six complementary winger with his work ethic and skill combination. Bear sustained a partially lacerated Achilles tendon in March but should be ready for training camp.

Michal Pradel stands 6-foot-5 in goal and transferred to the USHL midseason from Slovakia. He showed strong potential as a future starter after adjusting to North American hockey.

The Hurricanes focused on character players with projected NHL roles, continuing their organizational philosophy of drafting competitors.

Florida Panthers: B-

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
112 Mads Kongsbak Klyvo LW Frolunda Jr. Sweden Jr.
128 Shea Busch LW Everett WHL
129 Shamar Moses RW North Bay OHL
192 Arvid Drott RW Djurgarden Jr. Sweden Jr.
197 Brendan Dunphy LHD Wenatchee WHL
224 Yegor Midlak G Spartak Jr. MHL

The Stanley Cup champions made their first selection at 112th overall.

Mads Kongsbak Klyvo combines offensive tools with a strong 6-foot-2 frame. He made significant contributions for Denmark across multiple international tournaments this season.

Arvid Drott represents one of the younger players in this draft class and posted solid production in Sweden’s junior league.

Florida’s late start limited their draft volume, but they identified players with specific skill sets that match their organizational development approach.

Montreal Canadiens: A-

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
34 Alexander Zharovsky RW Ufa Jr. MHL
69 Hayden Paupanekis C Kelowna WHL
81 Bryce Pickford RHD Medicine Hat WHL
82 Arseni Radkov G Tyumen Jr. MHL
113 LJ Mooney C NTDP USHL
145 Alexis Cournoyer G Cape Breton QMJHL
177 Carlos Handel RHD Halifax QMJHL
189 Andrew MacNiel RHD Kitchener OHL
209 Maxon Vig LHD Cedar Rapids USHL

Another successful draft for Kent Hughes and his staff after trading their first-round picks for immediate help in Noah Dobson.

Alexander Zharovsky was acquired by trading up and brings top-six upside. He possesses some of the best hands in the entire draft class with a projectable 6-foot-1 frame.

Hayden Paupanekis provides size down the middle, though his production declined this past season.

Bryce Pickford had an outstanding season after going undrafted last year. He recorded 13 goals and 24 points in 18 playoff games from the blue line.

LJ Mooney measures just 5-foot-8, but that size becomes justifiable when drafting offensive talent at 113th overall.

Montreal’s approach balanced immediate organizational needs with high-upside skill selections throughout multiple rounds.

Ottawa Senators: B+

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
23 Logan Hensler RHD Wisconsin NCAA
93 Blake Vanek RW Stillwater HS-MN
97 Lucas Beckman G Baie-Comeau QMJHL
149 Dmitri Isayev LW Yekaterinburg Jr. MHL
181 Bruno Idzan LW Lincoln USHL
213 Andrei Trofimov G Magnitogorsk Jr. MHL

Logan Hensler provided solid value at 23rd overall after Ottawa traded down a few spots. He’s a well-rounded defenseman with complementary top-four upside thanks to his skating ability.

Blake Vanek, son of Thomas, posted big numbers in Minnesota high school hockey and will join the WHL next season.

Dmitri Isayev is listed at just 148 pounds, but he had a quality season in Russia and possesses the speed and skill to develop if he adds weight.

Bruno Idzan represents a fun selection as the first Croatian player ever drafted in NHL history. He posted excellent numbers in the USHL and projects as a potential top-nine contributor.

Ottawa balanced safe picks with high-upside selections while adding some historic significance to their draft class.

Tampa Bay Lightning: B

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
56 Ethan Czata C Niagara OHL
108 Benjamin Rautiainen C Tappara Liiga
127 Aiden Foster C Prince George WHL
151 Everett Baldwin RHD St. George’s HS-RI
193 Caleb Heil G Madison USHL
206 Roman Luttsev C Yaroslavl Jr. MHL
212 Grant Spada LHD Guelph OHL
215 Marco Mignosa RW Sault Ste. Marie OHL

Ethan Czata is a lanky center with solid skill and strong competitive traits. The Lightning have successfully developed similar player profiles in recent years.

Benjamin Rautiainen excelled in Finland’s top professional league with 33 points in 50 games as a rookie. He also represented Finland at the World Junior Championship. At 20 years old, he’s closer to competing for games in Tampa’s organization.

Tampa Bay focused on players who fit their development model while targeting centers throughout multiple rounds.

Toronto Maple Leafs: C+

Pick No. Player Pos. Team League
64 Tinus Luc Koblar C Leksand Jr. Sweden Jr.
86 Tyler Hopkins C Kingston OHL
137 William Belle RW NTDP USHL
153 Harry Nansi RW Owen Sound OHL
185 Rylan Fellinger RHD Flint OHL
217 Matthew Hlacar LW Kitchener OHL

Tinus Luc Koblar, a Slovenian-born center representing Norway, remains a very raw prospect. He needs significant physical development and offensive improvement to become the top-nine contributor teams typically target in the second round. He does show good hands in tight spaces.

After reaching for Koblar at 64th overall, the Maple Leafs found better value in Tyler Hopkins at 86th. He’s a center with good size, skill, and offensive upside who plays with pace.

William Belle brings a massive frame to the wing position, while Harry Nansi is among the youngest players in this draft class.

Toronto’s draft started poorly but recovered with several players who could develop into meaningful contributors.

Jump to:
Atlantic | Central | Metropolitan | Pacific

Wade Sterling avatar
Wade Sterling